California’s statewide prohibition on plastic carry-out bags has been in place for three years, but complications remain in terms of implementation. The situation is a reminder of how many details—and unknowns—accompany policy regulating material use.
California’s ban on single-use plastic bags, which became effective in November 2016, is currently the only statewide ban in place in the Nation.[1]
This article will report on the details of California’s legislation banning single-use plastic bags, which also includes restrictions on other types of shopping bags, along with an update on its implementation.
First, a Little History
California initially passed the statewide ban on plastic bags in September 2014 when then Governor Jerry Brown Jr. signed SB 270 (Padilla, Chapter 850, Statutes of 2014) into law. The legislation prohibited most grocery stores and pharmacies from distributing single-use plastic bags after July 2015, expanded the ban to convenience stores and liquor stores in July 2016, and directed certain retail outlets to charge a minimum of 10 cents for recycled paper bags and reusable grocery bags.
However, before the law was scheduled to go into effect, it was put on hold when a measure to repeal the ban qualified for the ballot. The American Progressive Bag Alliance (APBA) submitted more than 800,000 signatures by the December 29, 2014 deadline in support of a referendum on the law. With at least 555,236 of the signatures determined to be valid, the California Secretary of State announced in February 2015 that the referendum qualified for the November 2016 ballot.
However, in that 2016 vote, California voters backed the ban, and the legislation became effective immediately.
Enactment of SB 270 resulted in the addition of Chapter 5.3 (commencing with Section 42280) to Part 3 of Division 30 of California’s Public Resource Code.
Under the law, most grocery stores, retail stores with a pharmacy, convenience stores, food marts, and liquor stores may not provide single-use plastic carryout bags to their customers. The law does allow these retail establishments to provide customers with a certified reusable grocery bag or recycled paper bag at the point of sale for a charge of at least 10 cents.
Reusable grocery bags must be produced by a certified manufacturer and may not contain lead, cadmium, or any other toxic material. Importantly, SB-270 states that, to demonstrate compliance with this safety requirement, reusable bag manufacturers may obtain a so-called “No Objection Letter” from the U.S. Food and Drug Administration, a review process that can take the Agency some months to complete. Each bag also is required to:
- Have a handle and be designed for at least 125 uses;
- Have a volume capacity of at least 15 liters;
- Be machine washable or made from a material that can be cleaned and disinfected; and
- Be labeled with the name of the manufacturer, country of manufacture, a statement that it is reusable and designed for at least 125 uses, and—if it is eligible for recycling—instructions to return the bag to the store for recycling or to another appropriate recycling location.
Further requirements exist for reusable grocery bags made from plastic film, including specifications on the minimum amount of postconsumer recycled material that must be used to manufacture the bags.
In addition, the reusable plastic film products must be capable of carrying 22 pounds over a distance of 175 feet for a minimum of 125 uses and be at least 2.25 mils thick (1 mil is one one-thousandth of an inch). Labeling requirements for reusable grocery bags made from plastic film are also specified.
Further, reusable grocery bags made from plastic film that are compostable must meet ASTM International Standard D6400 for compostable plastics.
Retailers are allowed to retain the money collected from customers for certified reusable grocery bags and recycled paper bags. However, the money collected must be used to comply with the requirements of the law or to encourage customers to use reusable grocery bags.
Certification Requirements
The law requires that producers of reusable grocery bags provide California Department of Resources Recycling and Recovery (CalRecycle) proof of certification conducted by a third-party certification entity for each type of reusable grocery bag they manufacture, import, sell, or distribute in California. The third-party certification entity must be an independent, accredited (ISO/IEC 17025) laboratory.
To assist with this process, CalRecycle is required to provide a system to receive proof of certification online, and the state agency must also publish online the name, location, and appropriate contact information of certified reusable grocery bag products. Proof of certification must be submitted to CalRecycle biennially.
Third-party certification applications can be submitted through the Reusable Grocery Bag Reporting System (RGBRS). Once a proof of certification has been submitted, the name, location, and contact information of the reusable grocery bag producer, along with specified bag information, will be published on a list of Certified Reusable Grocery Bags and Producers (CRGBP).
CalRecycle was directed to establish a certification fee schedule to generate revenues sufficient to cover, but not exceed, the costs to implement and run the program. On April 16, 2019, CalRecycle approved a final draft of the regulations on the Administrative Certification for Reusable Grocery Bags. These regulations were approved on July 17, 2019 and became effective the same day (see California Code of Regulations (CCR), Title 14, Division 7, Chapter 4, Article 7, sections 17988.1-17988.7).
The relatively swift publication came as a surprise to some in the industry, as the regulations imposed additional certification requirements that have been perceived as rather onerous.
Status Report and Recommendations
The legislation also required CalRecycle to provide a report on the status of SB 270’s implementation. To comply with this requirement, on Feb. 25, 2019, CalRecycle published SB 270: Report to the Legislature: Implementation Update and Policy Considerations for Management of Reusable Grocery Bags in California.
In the report, CalRecycle listed several ambiguities in the statute that hinder the effective implementation of SB 270 and recommended four statutory revisions (listed below) to improve implementation of the law.
The first recommendation is to clarify the definition of “store” since it is not clear whether a store that primarily sells nongrocery items but also sell snacks is included the definition.
Suggestion number two is to resolve inconsistencies between SB 270 and the pre-existing statute for the At-Store Recycling Program governing the collection of reusable grocery bags for recycling. Some stores are removing collection bins for grocery bags due to these inconsistencies, therefore, the statute should be clarified to ensure stores continue to collect reusable grocery bags for recycling.
Third, CalRecycle asks for guidance on what criteria should be used to determine whether reusable grocery bags made from plastic film are “recyclable in this state.”
Finally, the agency recommends confirming the number of bags that customers paying via the WIC Program or with electronic benefit transfer (EBT) cards may receive without charge since some stores are only offering a single bag at no charge.
CalRecycle also recommended expanding the reporting requirements for stores and increasing the minimum fee for recycled paper and reusable plastic grocery bags. While stores currently are not currently required to provide data regarding bag usage, CalRecycle sent a letter requesting data on bag usage to 64 corporate offices covering 6,565 stores statewide. Responses to the letter resulted in information on customer transaction from 1,405 stores.
In 86% of those transactions, customers did not purchase a bag; in 11%, customers purchased a reusable grocery bag made from plastic film; and in 3%, customers purchased a recycled paper bag.
Questions Remain
During the first year of implementation, CalRecycle received more than 400 inquiries regarding the law. These included questions with respect to bag certification requirements, statutory definitions, and the role that FDA’s NOL process plays in confirming the safety of materials that are used to make reusable grocery bags.
Since many of the inquiries involved topics that were beyond CalRecycle’s statutory authority to interpret, the Agency collaborated with the Attorney General’s Office to develop a set of frequently asked questions to provide responses to stakeholder inquiries. Despite this clarity, a host of new questions have arisen due to the publication of the new certification regulations that came into effect in July.
Thus, while the mandate to ban single-use plastics bags has been clear, implementation of the ban has been fraught with less certainty.
This article is reprinted with the permission of Plastics Recycling Update. It first appeared in the Fall 2019 issue.
[1] Although Hawaii does not have a state-mandated ban of single-use plastic bags, plastic bags are banned in all counties in the state. In addition, several other states—including Vermont, Maine, Oregon, and New York—have passed single-use plastic bag bans; however, these bans will not become effective until 2020 or later.